Hi,

I refer to Module 21 of Selenium for Project JUNIT AND DATA DRIVEN FRAMEWORK. I am coding it in line with code provided and find a great discrepancy between Ant generated reports and errors reported through JUnit tests run on same classes. I even updated my project to Maven but ant genearted reports are not same as that of the Eclipse run reports. I am adding a Doc for the issue here

As you see the results of running JUNit and Ant are different with correct error messages in JUnit but offthe hand in Ant.

Example Ant O/P I get is:

run:

    [junit] Running tests.suite1.FirstSuiteRunner

    [junit] Tests run: 4, Failures: 0, Errors: 4, Skipped: 0, Time elapsed: 0.308 sec

    [junit] Test tests.suite1.FirstSuiteRunner FAILED

[junitreport] Processing /Users/<me>/Documents/ReportsRepo/rep/TESTS-TestSuites.xml to /var/folders/jb/j707q50968j173xhc3m9391h0000gn/T/null2062636952

[junitreport] Loading stylesheet jar:file:/usr/local/apache-ant-1.10.7/lib/ant-junit.jar!/org/apache/tools/ant/taskdefs/optional/junit/xsl/junit-frames.xsl

[junitreport] Transform time: 457ms

[junitreport] Deleting: /var/folders/jb/j707q50968j173xhc3m9391h0000gn/T/null2062636952

BUILD SUCCESSFUL

Total time: 2 seconds

Build is successful but there are 4 errors. I have run Project via maven, Junit, and build.xml and they all pass with correct errors reported.

This is my Build.xml file:

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="iso-8859-1"?>
<!DOCTYPE project [
]>

<project name="Module_Junit_Ant" default="usage" basedir=".">  

<!-- ========== Initialize Properties =================================== -->
    <property environment="env"/>
    
    <property name="ws.home" value="${basedir}"/>
	<property name="ws.jars" value="/Users/preetinderkaurvirk/Desktop/Selenium Code - Oct 18/Selenium Code - Oct 18/AllJars/"/>
    <property name="test.dest" value="${ws.home}/build"/>
    <property name="test.src" value="${ws.home}/src"/>
	<property name="test.reportsDir" value="/Users/preetinderkaurvirk/Documents/ReportsRepo/rep"/>

	

	<path id="testcase.path">


	    <pathelement location="${test.dest}"/>

	    <fileset dir="${ws.jars}">
	      <include name="*.jar"/>
	    </fileset>

	  </path>

    
    <target name="start-selenium-server">
        <java jar="${ws.home}/lib/selenium-server.jar"/>
   </target>

    <target name="setClassPath" unless="test.classpath">
        <path id="classpath_jars">
            <fileset dir="${ws.jars}" includes="*.jar"/>
        </path>
        <pathconvert pathsep=":" 
            property="test.classpath" 
            refid="classpath_jars"/>
    </target>

    <target name="init" depends="setClassPath">
        <tstamp>
            <format property="start.time" pattern="MM/dd/yyyy hh:mm aa" />
        </tstamp>
        <condition property="ANT" 
            value="${env.ANT_HOME}/bin/ant.bat" 
            else="${env.ANT_HOME}/bin/ant">
                    <!--<os family="windows" />-->
        			<os family="mac" />
        </condition>
        
    </target>
  
    <!-- all -->
    <target name="all">
    </target>

    <!-- clean -->
    <target name="clean">
        <delete dir="${test.dest}"/>
    </target>

    <!-- compile -->
    <target name="compile" depends="init, clean" > 
		<delete includeemptydirs="true" quiet="true">
            <fileset dir="${test.dest}" includes="**/*"/>
		</delete>
        <echo message="making directory..."/>
		<mkdir dir="${test.dest}"/>
        <echo message="classpath------: ${test.classpath}"/>
        <echo message="compiling..."/>
        <javac 
            debug="true" 
            destdir="${test.dest}" 
            srcdir="${test.src}" 
            target="13" 
            classpath="${test.classpath}"
        >
        </javac>
          <copy file="src/log4j.properties" todir="build/"/>
      </target>

    <!-- build -->
    <target name="build" depends="init">
    </target>

   
	  

    <target name="usage">
        <echo>
            ant run will execute the test
        </echo>
    </target>

	<path id="test.c">
	        <fileset dir="${ws.jars}" includes="*.jar"/>
	</path>
	
	  
	
	<target name="run" >  
		<delete includeemptydirs="true" quiet="true">
		            <fileset dir="${test.reportsDir}" includes="**/*"/>
				</delete>
			    <java jar="${ws.jars}" fork="true" spawn="true" />  
			    <junit fork="yes" haltonfailure="no" printsummary="yes">
				    <classpath refid="testcase.path" />  

			      <!--  <classpath ="${test.classpath}"/> -->  
			    <batchtest  todir="${test.reportsDir}" fork="true">  
			    <fileset dir="${test.dest}">  
			       
			        <include name="tests/suite1/FirstSuiteRunner.class" />
			        <!--include name="tests/suite1/FirstSuiteRunner.class" />-->
			        

			         
			    </fileset>  
			    </batchtest>    
			        <formatter type="xml" />  
				    <classpath refid="testcase.path" />  
			</junit>  
			    <junitreport todir="${test.reportsDir}">    
			        <fileset dir="${test.reportsDir}">  
			            <include name="TEST-*.xml" />  
			        </fileset>  
			        <report todir="${test.reportsDir}" />  
			    </junitreport>  
			</target>
	
	<target name="email" >
		       <java classname="util.SendMail" classpath="${test.dest}" classpathref="testcase.path" />
	    </target>

	
</project>

Could you inform where is this inconsistency coming from? And why errors reported are different ? 

Thanks